DVCPRO-HD-MXF-QT-MOV-FCUK!
June 24, 2008 7:50 am Computing, Reports, Technology, ranting, videoWorking on bigger projects with people in remote places always is a hassle. Today1 I received the long anticipated hard disk with the blue screen shots I should be working on. I popped it into the USB port but Windows thought the device was damaged and suggested to replace it. Luckily I remembered that the person who sent me the disk was a Mac user so I tried connecting the device on some Mac and it worked. Then my data-odyssey began…
I was plotting and scheming how I could convert a HFS+ file system into a platform friendly FAT32 but the easiest way is usually the one which takes you the longest. I copied every single file to the Mac’s hard drive, reformatted the disk to FAT32 and currently I am waiting as the files are transferred back onto the external hard drive.
Effectively this whole process ate up about one hour of my time. One hour I could have been working on the data instead of moving it around. But it wasn’t over already.
I remember requesting the files as, quote, “MXF files, straight from the P2 card” from my source but I haven’t paid attention to the fact that I won’t be supplied with dailies rather than excerpts from an edit. So I got the strangest files I’ve encountered so far: MXF.DV-QuickTimes that won’t play back on my PC - thanks to DVCPRO-HD compression. I strolled the web to get hold of the codec for QuickTime. To cut a long story short: For Windows users there aren’t any. So I spent the rest of the evening in the lab on a Mac with Final Cut Pro installed which read and played back the files no problemo re-encoding and reading some gaming magazine.
So it was recoding time - from HDVCPRO HD to QuickTime JPEG with about twice the file size that made me fondly remember the days back when I purchased my notebook — when 40 gigs meant a real big hard drive.
And now?
Now I’m reformatting the QuickTime files to TIF image sequences because Nuke doesn’t like JPEG QuickTime files. Time lost today: About 7.5 hrs — and counting.
What I have learned today:
- That sometimes it’s the cable, not the device.
- That you can access a Mac’s Disk Manager under Applications > Utilities.
- That this Mac can read NTFS disks — but not move data onto them.
- That I really can’t stand a Mac mouse’s acceleration and behavior.
- That there’s no way to read a DVCPRO HD QuickTime file on a PC.
- That a Mac has to have Final Cut Pro installed to play back a DVCPRO HD QuickTime file.
- That QuickTime exports the video files in the resolution currently displayed.
- That JPEG-QuickTimes (maximum quality) are twice as big as eqivalent DVCPRO HD QuickTime files.
- That Nuke doesn’t like QuickTimes with JPEG compression.
- That I should communicate better what files I need in what format and on what file system.
- Well, in fact yesterday now [back]

September 13th, 2008 at 19:15
I have come across a similiar problem as you and have and have found that there is a way to play DVCpro HD files on the PC. if you head over to http://dvfilm.com they have a utility called ‘Raylight 3.0′ that will allow the playback of dvcproHD material in several PC applications. Unfortunately this method isn’t free, but is worth it if you do lots with DVCproHD and/or MXF files. hopefully this is helpful to you.
September 14th, 2008 at 05:24
Thanks for the comment, Sean! In fact I already own Raylight 3 but haven’t tried yet to read the QT-files from hell with it! How would I know!
EDIT: Just tried it and it doesn’t work with Quicktimes, even if you change their extension to MXF because the QuickTime-container format is one sonuvabitch… I guess I have to look for fruity computers then — again.